January 26, 2012


My dad comes round for his dinner every Sunday evening and often we ask him what he would like to eat.  Usually he wants chicken or lamb but the other week, completely out of the blue, he suggested steak and kidney pudding.  Oh heck.

pud9jIt’s donkey’s years since I ate steak and kidney pudding and I have never ever made one.  My first thought was that it was too fiddly and long-winded and would take all day.  Then I thought well, if you’re going to make it at all, a gloomy Sunday in January is as good a time as any – what else is there to do?

So this is why, at the time of year when everyone else is dieting and detoxing, I found myself in the kitchen making one of the most fattening and stodgy dishes of all time.

We consulted a variety of cookbooks and it would seem there are two distinct methods.  Either make the suet pastry, put the uncooked meat inside and steam for 4-5 hours.  Or, cook the meat first before filling the pastry case and steam for 2 hours.

We decided to go with the second method as we thought it would be a good idea to see what the meat looked and tasted like before putting it in the pudding.  When I say “we”, this is because I was still under the weather with the lurgy so Nick did most of the work.  In the end, the preparation didn’t take all that long but you needed to be in the house for the cooking time, totalling 4 hours, to make sure the meat and the pudding don’t boil dry.

pud1 pud2

We used good quality braising steak and four lambs’ kidneys.  Nick chopped the kidneys small as although we like the flavour of kidney, we’re not too keen on chomping on a whole one.  They just melted away to nothing but there was plenty of kidney flavour.

pud3 pud4 pud5 pud6

We didn’t have a pudding basin the right size so Nick went shopping for one.  He found this 1 litre pot basin, exactly the right size and shape, in Tesco.  It didn’t have a price on it and when the assistant rung it up at the checkout it turned out to be 1p !!

First you make the filling, which is effectively a beef stew, and cook gently on the hob for two hours.  Whilst it’s cooking you have plenty of time to deal with the pastry.

We made traditional suet pastry, using proper Atora beef suet, and it’s easy to make as there’s no rubbing in to do.  He buttered the basin and rolled out the pastry to fit, leaving one third aside for the lid.  (He also reserved a small lump of pastry to make a lid for a separate pie – more about that in a mo.)

pud7 pud8 pud9 pud9a 

The pudding basin was filled almost to the top with the meat mixture and the lid put on, sealing the edges.  Then a layer of baking paper and foil, both with a large pleat in them, were fastened to the top with string, making a loop to act as a handle.  The pleat allows for expansion of the pudding and the string allows you to lift it out of the pan without scalding yourself.

 pud9c pud9b

The whole thing was placed in a large pan on an upturned saucer to act as a trivet, to keep the the basin off the bottom of the pan.  We steamed it for two hours, by which time Lulu was becoming very interested in the proceedings and had to be bribed with a chewy stick to stop fussing round the cook !!

pud9d pud9e pud9f pud9g

It looked pretty good when we took the foil off and it turned out beautifully – a man’s job of course.

pud9h pud9k

It tasted delicious.  We served it with the liquid left over in the pan when the meat filling was removed, which made an excellent gravy. 

We had reserved some of the filling to create a small, individual steak and kidney pie for my dad to take away with him and enjoy later in the week – hence the need for the extra bit of pastry.  He reported back that it was also scrumptious and has put in a repeat order !!

pud9lHere’s our version of steak and kidney pudding.


For the filling

750g lean braising or stewing steak, cut into 2-3 cm cubes

4 lambs’ kidneys, chopped very small

1 large onion, sliced

1 carrot, peeled and chopped into small cubes

1 tblsp plain flour

salt and pepper

a splash of Worcestershire sauce

1 bay leaf

2 sprigs thyme

oil for frying

For the pastry

350g self-raising flour

175g suet

salt and pepper

water to mix


Heat the oil in a large pan and brown the onion.  Remove from the pan.

Toss the meat in the seasoned flour and add to the hot oil in batches.  Fry until brown all over.

Return the onions and meat to the pan, add the carrot and herbs.  Add seasoning to taste along with the Worcestershire sauce.  Cover with water and simmer gently until the meat is tender, for about two hours, stirring occasionally .

Grease a one litre pudding basin with plenty of butter.

For the pastry, mix the self-raising flour, salt, pepper and suet in a large bowl.  Make a well in the centre and add cold water, a little at a time, stir to combine and make a dough, bringing it together with your hands. 

Reserve one third of the pastry for the lid and roll the rest into a large circle.  It needs to be big enough to line the basin to the top.   Roll out the smaller portion into a circle large enough to form a lid.  Line the basin with the pastry. 

Remove the bay leaf and thyme sprigs from the meat mixture and adjust the seasoning to taste.  Fill the basin with the meat, lifting it out of the pan with a slotted spoon, then add the liquid.  It should be wet but not too sloppy.  Any remaining liquid can be reheated to serve as sauce with the pudding.

Dampen the edges of the pastry with water, lay the lid on the top and press together to seal.  Trim to neaten the edges.

Cut a large circle of baking parchment (or greaseproof paper) and foil large enough to cover the basin with an overlap.  Make a pleat in the middle and lay on over the basin, the paper first then the foil on top.  Tie string around the basin just under the lip and make a double loop over the top to make a handle.  Trim if there is a lot of excess.

Place the basin in a large pan on top of an upturned saucer or small flan ring to act as a trivet.  Pour hot water into the pan to about half way up the basin.  Boil for two hours, topping up with boiling water as often as needed to make sure it doesn’t boil dry.

Lift the pudding out of the pan with the string.  Remove the string, foil and paper and carefully invert onto a large plate, preferably one with a lip in case there is any leakage of hot filling.

Stand back and admire your creation !! 

Serve with green veg and the reheated liquid, which can be thickened and seasoned to taste.

Serves 6-8


  1. Oh well done, and good thought about the little takeaway pie. We love s'n'k pud - I guess this means I'll have to make one now too...

  2. Jean, how enterprising of you. And I give credit to your sous-chef, of course.

    I didn't realize this would be a steamed pudding. I have made steak and kidney pie, which gets topped with pastry and baked. A steamed pudding would be just the thing to humidify our dry indoor air in the winter.

  3. Well done Nick I have never made a steak and kidney pudding. I hope Nigel never comes up with the idea of wanting one. If he does I will give him your recipe and let him get on with it :)) He is not well again at the moment, this is the second dose of whatever since Xmas! Diane

  4. That's so sweet that he had a little takeaway version!
    Looks lovely - turned out really well on the plate!

  5. I've never made one before, but now I have a recipe and step by step instructions. Merci beaucoup!

  6. Well done, I bet your Dad was thrilled,


  7. my mouth is watering... literally drooling over the keyboard... I love a good pudding and steak and kidney... wow!

  8. I love S & K pudding but I haven't made it for years - mainly because I'm the only one round here who'll eat kidneys. Your version looks so good for a winter's day.

  9. We used to have S&K pudding a lot when we were kids (it was always that or S&K pie on a saturday - we knew what day of the week it was by what we had for dinner). I haven't had it for years and now I am drooling at the thought. I shall visit the butchers when I go into town later and have a go

  10. We greatly enjoyed a steak and kidney pudding that Susan and Simon made and brought to us a year or two ago. I think that was the first and only such thing these Americans had ever had. But I love lamb kidneys. I used to be able to order them from the butcher at the supermarket near Chicago where I lived in the 1970s. Every time I ordered them, the butcher would say to me: "Your cat is going to have a feast over the next few days!" Little did he know that I was eating them myself, cooked with mushrooms and cream.

  11. Love comfort food like steak & kidney pud! I've never tried making one though, yours looks so good!

  12. Is there anything more comforting than a good suet pudding?